![](https://cdn.jiqizhixin.com/assets/code-modal__close-c158a550a9982aa92801c046548d72945aa912de6f2a012513132fdc02dfc379.png)
Auto Byte
专注未来出行及智能汽车科技
![](https://cdn.jiqizhixin.com/assets/auto-byte__qr-code-89b58c6d2398c12b7def0f2538cac5ff08727062918f9bad97f25b1d61aac000.png)
微信扫一扫获取更多资讯
![](https://cdn.jiqizhixin.com/assets/code-modal__close-c158a550a9982aa92801c046548d72945aa912de6f2a012513132fdc02dfc379.png)
Science AI
关注人工智能与其他前沿技术、基础学科的交叉研究与融合发展
![](https://cdn.jiqizhixin.com/assets/science-ai__qr-code-a12e4635c8d3968645bd2b6371981b65b0d21058c5a2c216aef80015b4eb7e43.png)
微信扫一扫获取更多资讯
9000多篇投稿,接收率只有15%,今年的AAAI你中了吗?
AAAI 2022 的审稿结果终于出了,但是,接收率只有 15%。有人认为,「这对社区是一种伤害。」
![图片](https://image.jiqizhixin.com/uploads/editor/c18f116c-4dfc-4eb1-b171-60e894b73dd5/640.png)
截图出处:https://twitter.com/guyvdb/status/1466089899698786305AAAI 今年的审稿结果,比往年来得晚了一天。由于没有任何通知,投稿的人只能干等,这使得往年的吐槽环节又往前提了一天。![图片](https://image.jiqizhixin.com/uploads/editor/ee6336e0-6d7e-4f8c-8f52-ff67701dfa1f/640.png)
截图出处:https://twitter.com/hbouammar/status/1465692077518299140![图片](https://image.jiqizhixin.com/uploads/editor/9891a32d-76da-45d7-917f-ed4ed0412bed/640.png)
截图出处:https://twitter.com/mmoffitt/status/1465675391297859588在知乎上,帮自己男 / 女朋友祈祷的帖子也早早地卷了起来。![图片](https://image.jiqizhixin.com/uploads/editor/a8404a6f-7cb3-4252-8301-4449ef613f4e/640.png)
![图片](https://image.jiqizhixin.com/uploads/editor/1f127fe9-623a-4f7b-843b-e22252f7b897/640.png)
截图出处:https://www.zhihu.com/question/497725523昨晚,投稿结果终于出炉。但令人意外的是,今年的接收率只有 15%(投稿量:9215;审稿量:9020;接收量:1349)。![图片](https://image.jiqizhixin.com/uploads/editor/213f4232-92c1-4604-9ed6-9a612b6301a1/640.png)
不出所料,评论区很快就被各种不满的声音所淹没。最大的槽点,当然还是接收率太低了。AAAI 的接收率,这几年就没这么低过:2020 年为 20.6%;2021 年略高,达到了 21%。今年的断崖式下跌几乎毫无征兆,之前邮件里建议的明明是 25%。有投稿者甚至怀疑 deadline 那天没出结果就是去降接收率了。![图片](https://image.jiqizhixin.com/uploads/editor/e3db28f6-130c-44e1-90c7-03d890303244/640.png)
截图出处:https://www.zhihu.com/question/497725523或许,这样的接收率和投稿质量有很大关系,之前就有不少审稿人反应,今年的投稿质量实在是太差了,有人甚至没写完就拿去投了。为了保住顶会声誉,AAAI 选择了最严厉的方式。![图片](https://image.jiqizhixin.com/uploads/editor/1953c153-fa13-4da4-91df-13707b388c64/640.png)
截图出处:https://www.zhihu.com/question/485476713但这么做的结果可能就是错杀一些真正的好论文。在比较热门的 CV、NLP 领域,这种被错杀的几率会更高,甚至可能让投稿人摸不着头脑。![图片](https://image.jiqizhixin.com/uploads/editor/2b05cf62-0f95-42a2-afac-9e716c107622/640.png)
截图出处:https://www.zhihu.com/question/497725523有人表示,自己明明拿了 4 个 accept,依然难逃被拒命运,就好像好多人都考到了优秀,但人家只要满分。难道真的是所在方向太卷了?![图片](https://image.jiqizhixin.com/uploads/editor/6de6e0cb-8866-4afa-b7b0-fcc73c1c7222/640.png)
截图出处:https://twitter.com/AvilaGarcez/status/1466047135275794439有人认为,这么低的接收率对整个社区是有害的,会迫使大家转向其他领域,去做一些渐进式的工作,因为这类工作比较容易润色。相比之下,NeurIPS 26% 的接收率要显得合理得多。![图片](https://image.jiqizhixin.com/uploads/editor/1007a028-6ca8-414f-aa96-f5f7012cf6a7/640.png)
![图片](https://image.jiqizhixin.com/uploads/editor/9d7da6e6-f3ab-493a-894a-7db7dd93e8b0/640.png)
截图出处:https://twitter.com/TobyWalsh/status/1466020146791661571除了接收率,审稿质量也是一大槽点,比如邀请没有投过 AAAI 的学生当审稿人,审稿人给的评论和论文不沾边等。当然,这已经是个老生常谈的问题了,但组委会似乎一直没找到什么合适的解决办法。![图片](https://image.jiqizhixin.com/uploads/editor/466a5aa3-1b90-4506-9938-f1ea68109e69/640.png)
截图出处:https://www.zhihu.com/question/485476713![图片](https://image.jiqizhixin.com/uploads/editor/d61990d9-26ad-490f-bc03-f5cd23bf664b/640.png)
截图出处:https://twitter.com/TobyWalsh/status/1466020572119199744还有人建议去投一些方向更加明确的会议,毕竟 AI 这个范围太大了,如果 AAAI 组委会要照顾各个子领域的中稿均衡性,热门领域的同学难免要当炮灰。